Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
96 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Proud Boys came to the rally in Atlanta. Then the tubas stepped in! (Original Post) jmbar2 Jun 14 OP
That is GREAT! hlthe2b Jun 14 #1
There's more of us than them! FirstLight Jun 14 #2
Wind instruments FTW! tanyev Jun 14 #3
Well, Technically Brass Metaphorical Jun 14 #11
I've always admired the subversive potential of brass to interrupt evil discourse jmbar2 Jun 14 #14
Brass WIND instruments they are just not sdfernando Jun 14 #27
My trombone playing son who played in the Eastman Wind Ensemble would disagree. Pacifist Patriot Jun 15 #56
Sad trombone got the last laugh in this video jmbar2 Jun 15 #66
Brass instruments are wind instruments. ShazzieB Jun 16 #88
They were fabulous! chowder66 Jun 14 #4
I LOVE this! Hekate Jun 14 #5
There were no decent bands in the Nazi parade in DC Walleye Jun 14 #6
The U.S. doesn't do these types of parades sdfernando Jun 14 #32
Yup, getting it crisp takes lots of practice. JHB Jun 15 #49
The drill team at the beginning of A Few Good Men Ilsa Jun 15 #55
I'm not in the habit of "rec'ing" Aggie-related posts... Paladin Jun 17 #90
Truth, I've seen better parades in my own hometown Walleye Jun 15 #61
I goggled it this morning cuz I didn't see enough parade footage to know if there were bands. CrispyQ Jun 15 #76
Maybe I just missed the good music that happened in the parade. Walleye Jun 15 #81
Made my day AnnaLee Jun 14 #7
Ouch! sheshe2 Jun 14 #8
There was a guy carrying a boogaloo brothers US flag. The yellow and black one. marble falls Jun 14 #9
What are they proud of? BOSSHOG Jun 14 #10
I'd like to say to the guy who was hiding his face that if you must... 3catwoman3 Jun 15 #45
One of their tenents is to keep masurbation to once a month. Not a joke. marble falls Jun 15 #64
Thank goodness for the tubas kacekwl Jun 14 #12
He wouldn't stop yapping GenThePerservering Jun 15 #82
As the tuba player in my high school's symphonic band, I approve. Aristus Jun 14 #13
Technically, is it a tuba or sousaphone? jmbar2 Jun 14 #15
The sousaphone is the portable, wearable version of the tuba. Aristus Jun 14 #21
Actually, I brlieve that was a euphonium. Conjuay Jun 14 #29
I don't know the tune usonian Jun 14 #16
I think it's a Klezmer tune, but don't know the name of it. jmbar2 Jun 14 #18
I am way uninformed on Klezmer. usonian Jun 14 #23
It's Bella Ciao! The Italian anti-fascist song chia Jun 14 #24
I missed WWII usonian Jun 14 #28
Wow! What a great choice of tune jmbar2 Jun 14 #38
So cool to know it's an anti-fascist tune, from Italia. First thought it was a polka, to mock the Nazi Boys. Timeflyer Jun 15 #68
A long-time favorite of Leftists thought crime Jun 15 #74
I was really hoping for BidenRocks Jun 14 #17
I was hoping for Midnight in Moscow NBachers Jun 14 #39
Another great tune - I've heard it but didn't know the background. jmbar2 Jun 15 #41
My son married his Bulgarian wife in Sofia. Walking through a park downtown, I heard a band playing this. I said, "I'm NBachers Jun 15 #46
Ciao Bella!!! nt Javaman Jun 14 #19
OMG, you're so right! tanyev Jun 14 #20
FIAT. Failed Italian Automotive Technology. NT usonian Jun 14 #30
Ha! I'm impressed they fit all 4 of them plus a camera inside that car. tanyev Jun 14 #33
Very famous anti-Fascist song. . . DinahMoeHum Jun 14 #22
You want to upset them? usonian Jun 14 #25
fuhrer's face NJCher Jun 14 #36
It's the limbic response. If it ain't part of the cult(ure), hate it. usonian Jun 15 #47
Most of the difference in sound can probably be attributed to the different mouthpieces. LudwigPastorius Jun 15 #40
Thanks! usonian Jun 15 #42
STG! JustAnotherGen Jun 14 #26
I grinned though that entire video BlueSpot Jun 14 #31
Kudos to everyone KentuckyWoman Jun 14 #34
OMG wryter2000 Jun 14 #35
Absolutely MAV-A-LAS!!! hamsterjill Jun 14 #37
the old tuba tooters back again. AllaN01Bear Jun 15 #43
BRILLIANT!! ailsagirl Jun 15 #44
I watched it twice NJCher Jun 15 #48
BRA EFFING VO!!! Faux pas Jun 15 #50
My favorite part MorbidButterflyTat Jun 15 #51
LMFAO. Whaa? No requests, boys? B.See Jun 15 #52
Tuba on the march Norrrm Jun 15 #53
K&R spanone Jun 15 #54
Needs more cowbell! Pacifist Patriot Jun 15 #57
Isn't that originally from SNL? markodochartaigh Jun 15 #58
Yep! That is indeed where it comes from. Pacifist Patriot Jun 15 #59
love how casual LEO is Skittles Jun 15 #60
They are very good players! Well-done! LymphocyteLover Jun 15 #62
Bwaaaah malaise Jun 15 #63
Now that musically owning magats. TexLaProgressive Jun 15 #65
OMG orangecrush Jun 15 #67
Played trombone in high school. HeartsCanHope Jun 15 #69
CLEARLY there are more of us than them! Trueblue Texan Jun 15 #70
Missed opportunity! ms liberty Jun 15 #71
Why are the police have taken a stance to protect the proud boys William769 Jun 15 #72
It looks to me like they're corralling them. nt GenThePerservering Jun 15 #80
Absolutely BRILLIANT!!! Stinky The Clown Jun 15 #73
+5 brass instruments of fascist repelling eShirl Jun 15 #75
jmbar2 ............. Upthevibe Jun 15 #77
This was something else I loved seeing peggysue2 Jun 15 #78
Happy Pride, boys! IjustDontlikeRepugs Jun 15 #79
ACLU legal observers present. That's how you do it! n/t Cheezoholic Jun 15 #83
This made me smile LetMyPeopleVote Jun 15 #84
Bella Ciao!!... AntiFascist Jun 15 #85
The tuba is a lethal weapon. Just ask Giuseppe Verdi. Bluetus Jun 15 #86
Hip Hip Hooray for the Tubas! mdbl Jun 15 #87
Rachel Maddow showed this video on her show last nite and I also listed it on Reddit and one Shellback Squid Jun 17 #89
That's wonderful! jmbar2 Jun 17 #91
In search of the elusive "brown note" just for the proud boys. nt Buns_of_Fire Jun 17 #92
Tubas of the Resistance Unite! jmbar2 Jun 17 #93
I laughed 'til I cried ailsagirl Jun 18 #94
The girl dancing with the flag behind those boys.... CoopersDad Jun 18 #95
Just saw this. Great stuff! 😄 TY electric_blue68 Jun 18 #96

FirstLight

(15,516 posts)
2. There's more of us than them!
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 10:09 PM
Jun 14

Never forget that... for all the bluster, weapons, and hate...we've got loudness, joy, and compassion for each other! ... not to mention great musical taste 😄

jmbar2

(7,075 posts)
14. I've always admired the subversive potential of brass to interrupt evil discourse
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 10:18 PM
Jun 14

Every city needs a brass band prepared for just for such occasions.

sdfernando

(5,812 posts)
27. Brass WIND instruments they are just not
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 11:20 PM
Jun 14

Woodwind instruments. Any instrument you have to blow air into to make a sound is a wind instrument.

55 year wind player here.

ShazzieB

(21,179 posts)
88. Brass instruments are wind instruments.
Mon Jun 16, 2025, 12:12 AM
Jun 16

Any instrument played by blowing through it is a wind instrument. All wind instruments are not brass instruments, but all brass instruments (tuba, trombone, trumpet, etc.) are wind instruments.




Walleye

(41,466 posts)
6. There were no decent bands in the Nazi parade in DC
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 10:12 PM
Jun 14

Could’ve had a few high school participations would’ve made it better

sdfernando

(5,812 posts)
32. The U.S. doesn't do these types of parades
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 11:28 PM
Jun 14

and you can tell. Very few crisp straight lines, uneven strides distances, lots of people out of step, rifles held at different angles, band instruments also held at different angles.

Hell, my high school band was way better than this!

Look at the parades in Russia and China…they train for this and it shows.

JHB

(37,792 posts)
49. Yup, getting it crisp takes lots of practice.
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 12:20 AM
Jun 15

There's a few specialized units who do that, like the Marine Drill Team, and cadet and midshipman corps at the service academies, but for typical units, after basic you'll get what was seen there: marching, not a showcase.

Ilsa

(63,046 posts)
55. The drill team at the beginning of A Few Good Men
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 01:40 AM
Jun 15

was dressed like Marines, IIRC. However, they were actually portrayed by the Texas A&M University Corps of Cadets Fish Drill Team according to Texas A&M Foundation. The Fish Drill Team, comprised of freshmen cadets, is a precision drill team known for its impressive performances, according to Texas A&M Admissions.

Paladin

(31,086 posts)
90. I'm not in the habit of "rec'ing" Aggie-related posts...
Tue Jun 17, 2025, 10:24 AM
Jun 17

...but it's a pleasure to do so, here. Great movie, fine marching by the Fish Drill Team.

CrispyQ

(39,993 posts)
76. I goggled it this morning cuz I didn't see enough parade footage to know if there were bands.
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 01:06 PM
Jun 15

The West Point marching band & one or more of the Army bands performed.

I didn't know this, though:

AI Overview
Yes, the U.S. Army has numerous bands, including those that perform as marching bands. These bands are part of the larger structure of U.S. military bands. Army bands play a variety of music styles and participate in ceremonies, concerts, and parades, both nationally and internationally.

Yes, the Marines have a marching band, known as "The President's Own" United States Marine Band. They are the oldest continuously active professional musical organization in the United States. In addition to the Marine Band, there are also ten Marine Corps Fleet Bands, which include marching bands.

Drum and Bugle Corps • United States Air Force Academy
Yes, the Air Force has a marching band, often referred to as the Ceremonial Marching Band. It is one of the performing ensembles within the United States Air Force Academy Band. The band performs at military ceremonies, parades, and other events, showcasing military precision and musicality.

Yes, the Navy has both a ceremonial/marching band and other musical ensembles. The Navy Band Northeast, for example, features a marching band that performs at street parades and other public events in the Northeast. The Navy also has other bands, including a concert band, brass band, and rock band, which can be seen at public concerts or parades. The U.S. Naval Academy also has a marching band and a drum and bugle corps that performs for various events.

Walleye

(41,466 posts)
81. Maybe I just missed the good music that happened in the parade.
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 01:19 PM
Jun 15

But I know the military bands are terrific because they play really well on the mall on memorial day and July 4. Really good musicians, course Trump doesn’t like music.

BOSSHOG

(43,356 posts)
10. What are they proud of?
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 10:15 PM
Jun 14

Are they potty trained? Have they mastered Easy Crossword Puzzles? Good Boy!

3catwoman3

(27,186 posts)
45. I'd like to say to the guy who was hiding his face that if you must...
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 12:10 AM
Jun 15

...hide your face while doing something, you are doing something you shouldn't be, and you have nothing to be proud of.

kacekwl

(8,473 posts)
12. Thank goodness for the tubas
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 10:16 PM
Jun 14

That one guy arguing with the PB was foolish. That's how violence starts. He should have been relocated.

GenThePerservering

(2,951 posts)
82. He wouldn't stop yapping
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 01:20 PM
Jun 15

reminded me of one of those annoying little ill-trained yappy dogs some people have.

Aristus

(70,423 posts)
13. As the tuba player in my high school's symphonic band, I approve.
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 10:17 PM
Jun 14

Tubas are not to be mocked!

jmbar2

(7,075 posts)
15. Technically, is it a tuba or sousaphone?
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 10:20 PM
Jun 14

I get them confused. But they are definitely a powerful defense against KKKrap.

Aristus

(70,423 posts)
21. The sousaphone is the portable, wearable version of the tuba.
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 11:06 PM
Jun 14

I played the sousaphone in marching band during football season, and then a standard concert tuba for performances the rest of the year.

usonian

(19,199 posts)
16. I don't know the tune
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 10:51 PM
Jun 14

Expected Hit the Road, Jack

At a Giants game, the Stanford wind/brass section (it was on the radio) prefaced The national anthem with the opening repeated A-flat notes of Tchaikovsky's fourth symphony IIRC. Striking.



Mighta woken up the sleepy one.

usonian

(19,199 posts)
23. I am way uninformed on Klezmer.
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 11:07 PM
Jun 14

Unless it's in one of Mahler's symphonies. I forgot the one. Not cheating tonight.

Great Mahler series. I heard every one.

https://exchange.prx.org/series/39638-embrace-everything-the-world-of-gustav-mahler

Timeflyer

(3,272 posts)
68. So cool to know it's an anti-fascist tune, from Italia. First thought it was a polka, to mock the Nazi Boys.
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 11:51 AM
Jun 15

thought crime

(509 posts)
74. A long-time favorite of Leftists
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 12:59 PM
Jun 15

And Bella Ciao was featured in the Netflix series, Money Heist !!

jmbar2

(7,075 posts)
41. Another great tune - I've heard it but didn't know the background.
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 12:07 AM
Jun 15

"Moscow Nights", originally titled "Leningrad Nights", is a Soviet patriotic song written by Mikhail Matusovsky and composed by Vasily Solovyov-Sedoy. It was later covered as "Midnight in Moscow" by Kenny Ball.

https://en.wikipedia.org › wiki › Moscow_Nights

NBachers

(18,750 posts)
46. My son married his Bulgarian wife in Sofia. Walking through a park downtown, I heard a band playing this. I said, "I'm
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 12:12 AM
Jun 15

not back home anymore." Beautiful parks, beautiful downtown; my son and I bought Cuban cigars to smoke together at the reception.

They now have a lovely and smart 8 year old daughter named Sofia.

tanyev

(47,173 posts)
20. OMG, you're so right!
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 11:05 PM
Jun 14



"Bella ciao" (Italian pronunciation: [ˈbɛlla ˈtʃaːo]) is an Italian song dedicated to the partisans of the Italian resistance, who fought against the occupying troops of Nazi Germany and the collaborationist Fascist forces during the liberation of Italy.

The exact origins are not known, but it is theorized to be based on a folk song of the late 19th century, sung by female workers (mondine) of the paddy fields in Northern Italy in protest against harsh working conditions. There is little evidence of the song being used during World War II, with the current "partisan version" only becoming widespread after it ended. Versions of "Bella ciao" continue to be sung worldwide as a hymn of resistance against injustice and oppression.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bella_ciao

DinahMoeHum

(23,083 posts)
22. Very famous anti-Fascist song. . .
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 11:07 PM
Jun 14

. . .sung in many languages. . .

. . .a version here sung by Ukrainian soldiers. . .

usonian

(19,199 posts)
25. You want to upset them?
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 11:14 PM
Jun 14

Spike Jones



Benny Hill/Boots Randolph. You can't heil and dance to the music at once.

Boots Randolph, a great performance.





Okay you experts, why is the second sax mellower than the first? They seem to be the same size, though I admit to being distracted.

NJCher

(40,733 posts)
36. fuhrer's face
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 11:45 PM
Jun 14

had me

I loved the comb mustache.

Hitler was a goofy looking fu@#$k, wasn't he? And so is trump. How do these buffoons get people to follow them?

I guess they cater to the lower half of the IQ spectrum.

usonian

(19,199 posts)
47. It's the limbic response. If it ain't part of the cult(ure), hate it.
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 12:13 AM
Jun 15


Works.

And did tech bros get taken to the cleaners!!!
Long time Silicon Valley investor sheds 💦💦 tears 💦💦 over bad decision. 💦💦
https://www.democraticunderground.com/100220378706
Greed and self-delusion "trump" brains/logic

One word of advice for those in Silicon Valley who followed Musk’s lead and sided with Trump. Leave. Don’t delude yourself that you are working to make crypto a part of global finance, minimising artificial intelligence regulation, helping start-up companies or protecting the interests of Silicon Valley. You have no sway. You are just cannon fodder.

LudwigPastorius

(12,973 posts)
40. Most of the difference in sound can probably be attributed to the different mouthpieces.
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 12:00 AM
Jun 15

Yakety Girl #1 is playing a metal mouthpiece, while Yakety Girl #2 is playing one made of hard rubber.

There are many other variables. The horn brand, reed hardness, and individual player's technique come into play, but mouthpiece is a biggie.

usonian

(19,199 posts)
42. Thanks!
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 12:08 AM
Jun 15

IIRC, My Dad had a black (so it's the hard rubber) mouthpiece.

He loved Dorsey and big bands, but his fav sound was Lombardo, IIRC.

🎷

KentuckyWoman

(7,140 posts)
34. Kudos to everyone
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 11:32 PM
Jun 14

Clearly law enforcement was there to stop the boys from instigating violence. Our folks stood firm.

That band that stepped up to drown them out prompting them to leave is wonderful.

NJCher

(40,733 posts)
48. I watched it twice
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 12:18 AM
Jun 15

Freaking hilarious.

We sang that song, too: "All you fascists bound to lose..."

Our musical group who led it are a group of labor lawyers who also are musicians!

MorbidButterflyTat

(3,342 posts)
51. My favorite part
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 12:57 AM
Jun 15

was the sweet young lady dancing with the US flag behind and above the fascist bullies!

She was great!!

Pacifist Patriot

(25,061 posts)
57. Needs more cowbell!
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 02:05 AM
Jun 15

Sorry. Family joke. My youngest kid is a professional trombonist. His siblings used to shout "needs more cowbell" to signal he should stop practicing and go to bed already. It was when we realized we had to beg him to stop instead of nag him to practice that we figured we had a professional musician in the house.

Musicians slay!

HeartsCanHope

(1,143 posts)
69. Played trombone in high school.
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 11:56 AM
Jun 15

Sat right in front of the drums and tubas. Tubas are VERY loud, even louder than the drums, imo. Loved seeing tubas, saxophones, trombones and drums, (sorry if I missed other instruments,) conducting sonic warfare against the little scared boys. Thanks so much for the post!

Trueblue Texan

(3,491 posts)
70. CLEARLY there are more of us than them!
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 12:45 PM
Jun 15

Yesterday was a huge success for our nation and I am fully of energy and courage from the participation!

ms liberty

(10,407 posts)
71. Missed opportunity!
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 12:47 PM
Jun 15

If the crowd pointed and yelled "proud boys" and then they did the sad trombone...oh, that woulda been epic!

William769

(59,147 posts)
72. Why are the police have taken a stance to protect the proud boys
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 12:47 PM
Jun 15

& not the other way around. I'm serious, watch the video again.

All hail the tuba's!

peggysue2

(12,027 posts)
78. This was something else I loved seeing
Sun Jun 15, 2025, 01:15 PM
Jun 15

The Art of Resistance. This time through music.

The one Proud Boy and protester were having an animated discussion that seemed to calm down as the musicians blasted away. Several of the PBs were rocking to the rhythm.

Another way to peacefully defang the opposition.

The cops/troopers did not look thrilled at the horns full tilt in their faces.

Good times!

Shellback Squid

(9,529 posts)
89. Rachel Maddow showed this video on her show last nite and I also listed it on Reddit and one
Tue Jun 17, 2025, 10:20 AM
Jun 17

of the players responded
https://www.reddit.com/r/Tuba/comments/1lbplhv/proud_boys_came_to_the_rally_in_atlanta_then_the/


"JonXP

2d ago

Hey, that's me and my friends. I'm the guy with the sousaphone you see towards the end. This was a pretty darn amazing thing to have been a part of."



I completely stole your header but admitted to it

jmbar2

(7,075 posts)
91. That's wonderful!
Tue Jun 17, 2025, 10:33 AM
Jun 17

I'm so glad they got the international recognition they deserve from Rachel! i hope it sets off a trend everywhere. And now I know what a Sousaphone looks like.

Many thanks.

jmbar2

(7,075 posts)
93. Tubas of the Resistance Unite!
Tue Jun 17, 2025, 10:48 AM
Jun 17

This is the moment in time for all tuba players to come to the aid of Democracy!. Maybe bagpipers will get inspired next.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Proud Boys came to the ra...