General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsNewsom didn't do anyone any favors by blowing up at the European leaders
...and like all macho displays in response to political challenges, the governor's ranting contained more heat than light.
California Governor Gavin Newsom tore into pathetic and embarrassing European allies for how they are responding to U.S. President Donald Trump, accusing them of rolling over as the White House upends NATO in its pursuit of control of Greenland from Denmark.
I cant take this complicity. People rolling over. I should have bought a bunch of knee pads for all the world leaders, Newsom, a Democrat and potential candidate for the presidency in 2028, told reporters at the World Economic Forums annual gathering in Davos.
He added: I hope people understand how pathetic they look on the world stage, at least from an American perspective. Its embarrassing.
Ive seen this in the United States, the supine Congress. Its time to stand tall and strong, stand united.
https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/gavin-newsom-european-leaders-pathetic-171337182.html
This guy is a wrecking ball. I hope people are waking up to what we are dealing with. This is code red, Newsom continued.
You guys are still playing by an old set of rules, everybody in the globe is, with this guy. Hes unmoored. Its the law of the jungle. Its the rule of Don, and I hope its dawning on the world what were up against. This is serious. This guy ishes not mad, hes very intentional. But hes unmoored and hes unhinged.
The Democrat also accused leaders of saying different things in public and in private about Trump. Everybodys talking behind his back. Theyre laughing at him. Meanwhile, theyre sucking up to him. Its embarrassing This is not diplomacy, its stupidity, Newsom said.
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/gavin-newsom-slams-pathetic-us-allies-over-donald-trump/ar-AA1UA51y
...while it's nice to see someone standing up to Trump, it has to be bemusing for the European leaders to see the governor bashing them for something that is rapidly spinning out of control in his own country, ignoring their own individual interests are just as rapidly turning away from America because of our voters' insistence in again elevating Trump back onto the world stage.
It's not the Europeans' responsibility to bring Trump to heel; not as much as they are charged with looking after their own interests; and now they're turning away from decades of cooperation on concerns which the U.S. is rapidly abandoning support for, both materially and rhetorically under Trump.
They can reasonably ask where they can rely on America right now for anything other than the inevitability of some arbitrary punitive action directed at them at the point of Trump's latest pique.
They don't need to growl at Trump or beat their chests like teenagers in a school fight. They have democracies which will determine whether negotiation or fighting makes sense to their interests.
And certainly on this world stage, at this world economic summit, cooperation between nations is meant to take precedent over the internecine squabbling that Trump would like everyone else to descend into while picking over the rubble he's caused.
Gov. Newsom should be careful imagining the Europeans don't know how to take care of themselves in the face of autocratic figureheads pushing their weight around. Their people know how to take to the streets to demand the changes they want; less so here in the States, albeit learning.
But more than that obviation, Europeans must have had their fill of Americans talking down to them right now, their countryfolk now at the mercy of political outcomes which Newsom and others in America have failed to effectively manage among our own people.
Personally, I've long had my fill of macho politics that substitutes volume for effect or substance.
If Newsom wants Europeans to do something more to confront Trump; if he has specific ideas beyond being 'tall and strong;' he should spell those out more succinctly than the full-throated deriding he offered them today for practicing diplomacy at a diplomatic forum - do the work of diplomacy with our European allies so that we can all as he admonished, "stand united."
BannonsLiver
(20,303 posts)Imagine defending a federalist society republican stooge to the death while criticizing a Dem leader who dares to speak up about an insane tyrant. Ive seen it all. 🙄
LR3
(137 posts)What Dems really need is more caution and timidity
More caution, maybe. More timidity? No fing way!! We need to amplify whats right and drown out what is wrong.
sheshe2
(96,255 posts)newdeal2
(4,895 posts)Why didnt Germany take care of their own problem?
brer cat
(27,402 posts)Talking down to people is not a good look, especially those already slammed by trump.
MorbidButterflyTat
(4,248 posts)And he was addressing the press, not European leaders.
You can see and hear him for yourself.
Thanks to TexasTowelie:
https://www.democraticunderground.com/1322103359
This knee jerk Dem hate is really getting old.
TheProle
(3,919 posts)Skittles
(169,865 posts)NO ONE should be bending the knee to that fucking tyrant - NO ONE
TheProle
(3,919 posts)The previous poster said that Newsom was addressing the press and the quote says "world leaders." Not in a position to watch vids right now, so just looking for confirmation of facts.
Kingofalldems
(40,070 posts)BannonsLiver
(20,303 posts)IcyPeas
(24,967 posts)Newsom and every other rational American are fed up with trump. He's robbing us blind. He is most likely a pedophile of the worst kind. He's declared war on American cities and that doesn't look like it's stopping any time soon with all the money being poured into it.
Everyone does talk behind his back. The emperor wears no clothes.... until someone says it out loud.
I wish and hope more leaders would speak up. We hear often that dems can't do anything because we're the minority blah blah blah... but leaders have voices. The press are useless. The words don't have to be perfect but somebody has to start saying out loud what we're all thinking..
bigtree
(93,476 posts)...as I have in the op.
I don't know what you're calling 'Dem hate' but I can assure you that I don't have a modicum of hatred for Gavin Newsom, so I'm not going to spend time on that.
I've enjoyed a long enough life that I've been privileged to bring my support to each and every Dem nominee for president, and in my district and state, as well.
In those instances, I often find myself sprinting far ahead of most of the Democratic debate over their fitness or efficacy of their candidacy; looking behind and seeing not the actual opposition tearing them down, but our own professed Democrats creating drag on them.
If this fellow runs for president (I don't vote in Ca,), and I think that's what you;re getting at here, you won't find a stronger supporter when he's nominated, and I won't drag him to the ground with complaints about him being 'weak' on something or the other, or grind down on his messaging.
I don't think he did that effort any favors, and, that's what I'm getting at. he's not a candidate, but if he's seeking my vote in a primary race that's likely to have an expansive field, maybe he could demonstrate the professionalism and diplomacy that I expect from my president in publicly relating what he wants to other leaders around the world, especially our allies.
That's the leadership that I expect and have grown fond of in my decades of this.
We live in a world where the U.S.'s success has been greatly enhanced by our ability to not only forge good cooperative relationships with other nations, but our respect for their own ability to make those decisions for themselves, whether or not they want to have those relationships with us.
Although Gov. Newsom gave their sovereignty lip service after berating them, he did so with the assumption that European leaders had an obligation to stand with a California governor whose country doesn't seem to have it's sit together enough to even save his own state from Trump yet, admittedly, despite how 'tall and strong' he's decidedly been in opposition.
Newsom hasn't yet figured out how to stop Trump, any more than leaders who aren't in any way a part of the solution to removing him from power. He has a Dem dominated state with a solid, workable Dem majority. He can't assume everyone else can just muscle their way through this crisis.
What's wrong with just leaving it at speaking his mind to those leaders, and not coming out and deriding them at the same time Trump is attacking them from the other side? Wouldn't it be more effective to continue to appeal to them in private, instead of trying to emasculate them in this forum?
I got the sense here that Newsom is on a learning curve, and it's frankly surprising to see him come forth with a response that's so scolding and condescending. I'd think he'd realize Europeans have had more than enough of that kind of arrogance from the U.S. already, and would offer a different face to allies who'v been treated as doormats lately, despite their past sacrifices for this country.
I mean, he's not actually the boss of them.
cachukis
(3,695 posts)least from what I have seen. I have been in a few pubs and taverns where offense is a challenge for repaste or rebuttal.
The Eurpoeans need a calling out. They have been milking our largesse while we have been reaping financial rewards. Trump has played this well.
The Eurpopeans have been exposed, but we have had the best of it. Trump has brought this to a head.
The symbiosis is unraveling. It has been good while it lasted. The pax romana inevitably ends.
Not sure this will turn out well.
Regardless, I suspect American comeuppance has been awaited by the world.
We'll see how well our oligarchs manage our needs.
Not particularly confident watching oligarchs elsewhere.
creon
(1,949 posts)He said what needed to be said
Greg_In_SF
(916 posts)run for President, he needs to act more professional.
Starbeach
(307 posts)He at least represents American disgust with Trump. But this is a thoughtful post.
creon
(1,949 posts)full stop
WTF, NO ONE SHOULD BEND THE KNEE FOR DONALD FUCKING TRUMP
cachukis
(3,695 posts)media with gish gallop entertainment. The world is consumed; all of us. Newsome is a response.
We are not going back to what we have experienced as normal.
Who in America can appeal to the entertained American so inured to the last ten years of trump?
Newsome has a piece of the stage and now our scrutiny from a past era.
We aren't going back.
Can he manage? He is cutting his teeth unlike many others. He is trying to manage the great divide of voters and annoying many of us on the left.
But the leftists want radical change and the Bernie's and AOC's want to stretch and pull us to social liberal world view.
Newsome is making us all think. He sees the trans issue as polarizing. He is right. He sees a billionaire tax as disruptive to the California economy. He is right.
He is calling out the appeasement in the European Union. He is right.
Will he refine his argument and presentation? At least he is presenting a standard to which we will all compare.
Good for democracy, no?
Read my response #20
Reminds me of the quote "speak your mind even if your voice shakes"
leftstreet
(39,048 posts)fujiyamasan
(1,319 posts)Trump cant be negotiated with in good faith. He recognizes nothing but strength and a show of force. It doesnt have to be physical but they definitely need to buck up and show resolve.
Many European leaders have kicked these security concerns down the road for decades, with little to show in terms of a unified military and hardly any domestic energy supplies. They have already been victims of Putin (who they similarly tried to appease). Trump is bullying them because he can.
Newsom is sounding a warning. Hopefully theyll listen.
boston bean
(36,875 posts)But Europe can also not be his doormat. It should be said. This is how we fight to win. Pull the cloak of weakness back.
Raine
(31,108 posts)Renew Deal
(84,727 posts)Europe thought they could play along. They are just realizing that the world they thought they left behind is back and has been since at least 2022.
haele
(15,133 posts)Last edited Tue Jan 20, 2026, 08:32 PM - Edit history (1)
And got lulled by Biden's US policy and economics trying to help everyone dig themselves out of COVID.
It's going to hurt them bad to stand up no matter if they kneeled to the Project 2025 clowns first, or turn their backs on the US, and they know it.
This is a pull off the bandaid too early quickly or slowly situation, and the EU, at the very least, needs to quickly figure it out as one voice instead of 1/3 of the EU flipping the bird to *Rump, 1/3 dithering around because of, well, investments and their own billionaire boi clubs - with the final third remaining quiet because they were going to follow the majority no matter what was decided.
Dithering makes it worse.
The Billionaire elites and resource Oligarchs can't sustain their own wealth and luxury once they start crashing the economy. And it's going to be a hard empire ending crash; too much money is separated from real assets and based on speculation.
Rich people honestly think working people trying to keep from dying off will happily stop rebuilding effort for themselves and their families or communities - for otherwise worthless inflated money instead of something tangible.
On edit, why does autocorrect think lulled is not a word?
TimeToGo
(1,439 posts)And got killed by Biden's US policy and economics trying to help everyone dig themselves out of COVID.
haele
(15,133 posts)Autocorrect I'm always having to turn off.
TimeToGo
(1,439 posts)Fiendish Thingy
(22,259 posts)That nails it right there.
GoodRaisin
(10,760 posts)themaguffin
(4,950 posts)LonePirate
(14,343 posts)They need to stop fellating him as Newsom implied.
Irish_Dem
(80,156 posts)Time for being sweet, nice, and sending letters to be totally over.
anciano
(2,203 posts)Qutzupalotl
(15,684 posts)kimbutgar
(26,932 posts)He is too bothsiderism !
Escape
(384 posts)More please, from every other Democrat in the country.
We are at WAR. We can't pretend it's a debate, a difference of opinion or a time for diplomacy.
The world is very angry at the United States...and they should be. We need to let them know that WE are just as angry.
Newsom '28!
Emile
(40,901 posts)Chalco
(1,438 posts)ancianita
(43,039 posts)leader over in Davos doing any better. Do you? Nope.
Don't start chipping away at perfectly good Democratic leaders just because they're not perfect.
Newsom is the leader of the 4th largest economy on the planet. If what he thinks and says isn't good enough for you, just know that you're not helping the Democratic cause.
bigtree
(93,476 posts)...I didn't vote for him.
And, btw, I support EVERY Democratic nominee like my own kin, but people have a lot of nerve expecting fealty to one potential candidate right now in what should be an expansive field of hopefuls in that future election.
Trump's belittling the European leaders like he doesn't live in a glass house, and here comes the Democratic governor of California acting as if he doesn't live here too.
Do you really think the Europeans really care that a Democratic governor is scolding them about their inability to control Trump, any more than Newsom's 'tall and strong' stuff has controlled him so far?
The Europeans can't remove him from office, and they should be loath to do anything that hurts their own interests now that the U.S. has all but abandoned any pretense of cooperation or care for European concerns and is insisting that the world revolve around America.
This paternalism that pretends that the U.S. doesn't need Europe more than they need us is dangerous revisionism. It's the U.S. who is isolating itself away from being able to advance our own interests; the Trump regime now reduced to bullying them, as they're too arrogant to treat them as allies instead of obstacles and do the actual work of diplomacy.
What I can't understand is why the governor thought it was a good idea to come out of what he said were private discussions and betray those confidences, instead of just contiuning to press them behind the scenes to do whatever he wanted.
Is this an example of his foreign policy approach - talking down to and treating foreign allies like he's their boss? I mean, he was at a diplomatic conference complaining about diplomacy being practiced by people who have more experience with autocratic regimes than a Ca. governor.
He's sitting on a workable Democratic majority in his state, making all of his excellent actions in that state behind a Democratic legislature, and his behaving as if everyone else has that political advantage.
It's the same with the attacks on Democrats here at home who have none of the advantages of a majority to do what Democrats naturally, reliably, and successfully do when they hold the most seats in the legislature.
It's just sophistry, really, with such a simple portrayal of the challenges to Europe, coupled with zero regard expressed for their OWN prerogatives. Hell, he didn't even bother to mention the pushback that we saw from several of the European leaders, and really demagogued their efforts to resist Trump, knowing little to nothing about the state of their respective nations' political affairs from his confortable seat in Cali.
European leaders aren't Trump, and they certainly aren't Trump supporters. They don't deserve to be talked down to by Americans who have foisted this cretin on the world with our own refusal to stand up to the bully. He walked all over California, even as the governor stood 'tall and strong.'
If he wants support for being the 'Democratic advantage' he needs to win the nomination for president. But in the interim, with so much at stake for me personally, I will not fail to speak my mind about what kind of leader I want to represent me, and no one should automatically assume that the Ca, governor speaks for me on everything that comes out of his mouth.
I do understand how challenging it is watching republicans bull their way through with their narrow majority; ignoring rules and laws as they consolidate their temporary power.
But the answer to all of that isn't to adopt the same autocratic attitude that assumes people can be cowed into doing what we want. The principles of coalition-building and cooperation still apply.
Newsom or any other politician is going to find it's like spitting in the wind trying to put things back in order by dictating down to the people they intend to lead. That machismo is a myth that assumes leaders do the heavy lifting, instead of the people they govern.
It's one thing to stand up to enemies, and yet another to generate the cooperation from allies that is essential to accomplishing more than just domination and control. It's not something new, it's a basic formula for dealing with our neighbors like friends and not just opportunities for us to advantage our own country.
One thing that has been distressing to me is the way that our politics has devolved into these false, zero-sum calculations that treat humans in the way of politics as abstract obstacles.
It's a recipe for chaos and anarchy, and makes is all ripe for domination by someone completely oblivious to what the people want, who thinks we should be fighting their personal battles instead of tending to our own needs.
I said above that the governor seems to be on a learning curve. I'd hope one of the first things he gets right is that he'll need to do more than merely communicate what he wants to the people he intends to lead, and that he learns to form coalitions of support behind his ideals and initiatives among people who aren't in his immediate orbit and influence.
ancianita
(43,039 posts)he supports a minority at the federal level which isn't as powerful as he is as governor of the 4th largest economy (therefore rightfully at Davos), and again, is frustrated that
-- by the felon contemptuously abdicating the international order, and
-- Western allies being passive in the face of that and threats to their safety,
he doesn't hear the kind of fight from them that both he and we back home have waged against the felon's reckless lawless damage has done to our relatively stable democratic economy, harming the American people.
I think he needs to let them know that while they are shifting into an offensive posture, they should still be on the side of the American people, 77% of whom did not and have never voted GOP. . He says, "from an American perspective... It's time to stand united." When he says to them "This is diplomacy? Trump's a T-Rex, you mate with him or he devours you." ... he's sharing an image of what we've experienced in the U.S.
I didn't say Newsom is the Democratic cause. I say the Democratic cause in the sense that Newsom himself backs the Democratic cause that we back, which is aligned with causes of democratic states of the EU.
Our common Democratic cause is fostering economic growth, social justice, opportunity, freedom through responsive government;
advocating for policies like workers' rights, environmental protection, healthcare access, and civil rights -- all that while balancing economic interests with social progress to create an inclusive society where all individuals can thrive. Historically, this includes New Deal-era social programs that built modern production and trade that historically helped our allies on many levels.
So, imo, backing Newsom helps the Democratic cause. Not criticizing his criticisms of other leaders doesn't.
I've read your other posts in the thread -- but just not until after I'd given my opinion of your op's criticism, is all.
The op triggered in me my own frustration with those a) who've been quick to baselessly criticize any Democratic leader when they don't say or do what we think best, or b) who act as if any one mistake or decision is make-or-break in trust. California has a lot of international trade agreements. These people know Newsom. His opinion matters in world affairs. He's not a diplomat. He's a significant world trade leader. If one comment goes viral where he wants more from allied leaders, I'm seeing that he's honest with journalists in criticizing those leaders for being way too passive by not reining in their own global oligarchs who cozy up to the felon "with crowns and prizes."
NotHardly
(2,705 posts)OGBuzz
(31 posts)I'm a big Newsom fan but this rant about European complicity and offering to bring knee pads was not his best moment. How about complicity in Washington and throughout America? Start there, your own back yard. Trump is in charge of the largest military and the largest economy on the planet and Europe is understandably afraid. Europe didn't elect this lunatic nor did they grant him the total and ultimate powers of a king.
GusBob
(8,149 posts)And how would one compare this to todays performance by Trump I wonder?
BadgerKid
(4,964 posts)JonAndKatePlusABird
(367 posts)I consider it tough love. If European leaders are such shrinking violets that this offends them, no wonder people like Trump see them as bumps in front of a steamroller.
bigtree
(93,476 posts)...which is much more damning that reacting to it.
Arthur_Frain
(2,270 posts)IMHO, its time for a little scorched earth response. If GN is the guy thats going to give that to them, Im behind him 100%.
Obamas high road netted us fuck all.
markodochartaigh
(5,112 posts)allowed some a few more rounds of high tea in their Ivory Towers.
crimycarny
(2,039 posts)When I saw that, on the one hand, I agreed with the frustration, but on the other hand, I kind of cringed. And I am a HUGE fan of Gavin and the way he is fighting back here at home. However, I don't think it was so over the top that it'll be headline news for weeks.
I think Andy Beshear handled that question more diplomatically, while not coming off as weak or timid. Andy kept the focus on bashing Trump, which I felt was a smarter approach.
Maybe Gavin can take note and tweak his responses a bit.
NOTE: DU'er senseandsensibility highlighted Andy Beshear's response in an earlier post. Here is a video of it.
tritsofme
(19,822 posts)Diplomats and world leaders are not domestic political actors and do not react as such, he should not expect them to and should not have publicly excoriated them.
Further alienation of our European allies is not what we need from a potential future president.
Sugarcoated
(8,238 posts)I don't think it's a bad look. Just my 2 cents.
DJ Synikus Makisimus
(1,215 posts)should be anywhere near the nuclear trigger. I'm sure Gavin generated lots of hits on his social media, though, and made bank bigly on the commercials featuring other "influencers." Newsom is the star of his own TV show, and he has a bright future as a game show host.
markodochartaigh
(5,112 posts)know how things will play out. But I'm more than happy to recommend this post for the effort which went into it as well as the level of discussion which it has elicited.
For what it's worth, I think that we are too focused on the incorrect target. As sad as it is to believe that nuclear weapons, the world's largest military, and so much of the US economy is under the thumb of someone as compromised on every level as Trump, I don't think that he is the root of the problem. In fact, I see him now as the Republican party's biggest problem. I think that he should be allowed to tear their party apart. The US' authoritarian problem came from the right and it will have to be solved by having a non-authoritarian right wing solution. To be viable a democracy must have at least two viable parties committed to democracy and the US is one party short. Unfortunately a moderate left wing party and a progressive left wing party would only split the vote allowing the right wing party to win. Eventually the electorate might be educated and engaged enough to fight the right wing party, but we are not there now nor will we be soon enough. Nevertheless, an ignorant and apathetic electorate got us here and I think that this is one target which we must focus on immediately.
Another target is our oiligarchs. They are as much the reason that we are losing our democracy as the electorate. Reining them in, if it is possible, will cause extreme short-term damage to the economy and stock market. But they have proven that they are enemies of democracy. If Europe does use its trade bazooka it could be a start to reining them in. It might be possible to get enough Republicans on board if all of the Democratic members of Congress stuck together to craft legislation here.
Leaving Trump to thrash and trash the Republican party will do incredible damage to the US and our institutions. But I think that if he were replaced now by a polished authoritarian more acceptable to the corporate Republicans, and still acceptable to the maga base, the damage would be worse. It took half a century to get rid of Franco. Several African countries and North Korea still have authoritarian Strong Leaders.
Jack Valentino
(4,486 posts)who have the courage and are willing to take Trump on, in his own ballpark....
I realize this is an article that you reposted,
but I would not have chosen to repost it here and now...
bigtree
(93,476 posts)...you didn't even bother to address what I wrote.
Just boosting ONE possible candidate for president three years from now and acting as if I should regard him as my leader just by virtue of his ambition and his party affiliation. I support EVERY Democratic NOMINEE for president. That contest has yet to occur.
If you bother to read what I wrote... if he has the leadership skills that enable him to do more than just tell us all what to do, and will bother to listen, I believe I've provided not only advice he can use, but made clear what I want in a candidate for president.
The nerve of anyone assuming I should give fealty to someone because of en election in three years and stifle myself... it is an amazing way to address or regard people you apparently want to support this man.
What is this thing with bullying people, acting as if Newsom or any other politician should be treated like the boss of anyone they intend to represent? Talk about in-kind politics. This is ridiculous.