Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

RandySF

(88,321 posts)
Fri Jul 3, 2026, 04:16 AM Friday

PA-10: Perry Calls For Repeal of 17th Amendment and Give State Legislatures Power to Elect Senators

The Capitol Region Republican has signed on as a co-sponsor to Rep. Keith Self’s (R-Texas) resolution (H.J.Res.198) to repeal the 17th Amendment and restore the Founders’ original vision for the United States Senate by returning the selection of U.S. Senators to state legislatures.

The 17th Amendment, ratified in 1913, allows voters to cast direct votes for U.S. senators. Prior to its passage, senators were chosen by state legislatures.

“The current system has given us six-year politicians more focused on national ambitions and the institution of the U.S. Senate than on the states they serve,” said Self. “Our Founding Fathers designed the Senate to protect state sovereignty and act as a check on federal overreach. If senators are supposed to represent their states, then the states should choose them. Repealing the 17th Amendment will restore that constitutional balance and make the Senate more accountable to the people of Texas and every other state in the union.”

According to the National Archives, “The Constitution, as it was adopted in 1788, made the Senate an assembly where the states would have equal representation. Each state legislature would elect two senators to six-year terms. Late in the 19th century, some state legislatures deadlocked over the election of a senator when different parties controlled different houses — Senate vacancies could last months or years. In other cases, special interests or political machines gained control over the state legislature. Progressive reformers dismissed individuals elected by such legislatures as puppets and the Senate as a “millionaires’ club” serving powerful private interests.”



https://politicspa.com/perry-calls-for-repeal-of-17th-amendment-and-give-state-legislatures-power-to-elect-senators/149474/

12 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
PA-10: Perry Calls For Repeal of 17th Amendment and Give State Legislatures Power to Elect Senators (Original Post) RandySF Friday OP
or maybe he just wants more republican senators lol nt msongs Friday #1
Bingo Martin Eden Friday #10
The odds of being killed by a vending machine are better than the odds this thing is ever ratified. eggplant Friday #2
Hopefully Perry's days in office are numbered. Dunc Friday #3
Or...a way to ensure only white property owning men of wealth were senators JT45242 Friday #4
we need to add d.c. and puerto rico. mopinko Friday #8
MAGA.... Stuckinthebush Friday #5
Next will be the 14th and 19th Amendments. Lonestarblue Friday #6
Giving power to the states ninjanurse Friday #7
This niche-cult movement goes back at least thirty year that I know of. John1956PA Friday #9
. . . John1956PA Sunday #11
nope themaguffin Sunday #12

eggplant

(4,264 posts)
2. The odds of being killed by a vending machine are better than the odds this thing is ever ratified.
Fri Jul 3, 2026, 05:05 AM
Friday

Why would the people give up their vote?

JT45242

(4,258 posts)
4. Or...a way to ensure only white property owning men of wealth were senators
Fri Jul 3, 2026, 05:38 AM
Friday

It was literally like the house of lords, except very indirectly elected.

It is the only not gerrymandered vote for federal legislature or the president available.(The Dakota territory with virtually no people was split into two states to give 3 extra electoral college votes to the party of racism and hatred. )

The apartheid rule plans are so blatant that I feel like we are all living in the novel, cry the beloved country.

mopinko

(74,286 posts)
8. we need to add d.c. and puerto rico.
Fri Jul 3, 2026, 06:46 AM
Friday

and throw the dakotas in the face of anyone who howls about “power grabs”.

Lonestarblue

(13,672 posts)
6. Next will be the 14th and 19th Amendments.
Fri Jul 3, 2026, 06:20 AM
Friday

Republicans would love to strip minorities of citizenship and prevent women from voting. The only amendment I'd like to see repealed is the 2nd, and that will never happen.

John1956PA

(5,155 posts)
9. This niche-cult movement goes back at least thirty year that I know of.
Fri Jul 3, 2026, 07:05 AM
Friday

This goofball call to change the way senators are elected goes back at least as far as the 1990s, even before partisan politics was prominent on the web. I think that the sinister operators who cursed the nation with Limbaugh and Gingrich started it.


Latest Discussions»General Discussion»PA-10: Perry Calls For Re...