Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Science
Related: About this forumWhat Causes Lightning? The Answer Keeps Getting More Interesting. (Quanta, 5/6)
https://www.quantamagazine.org/what-causes-lightning-the-answer-keeps-getting-more-interesting-20260506/This really should be read in its entirety, but here are a couple of snippets to show why the findings about lightning are getting more interesting:
-snip-
Dwyer knew that a Russian physicist, Aleksandr Gurevich, had shown in 1992 that such a runaway electron could unleash a cascade of perhaps 100,000 electrons, akin to the avalanches that initiate sparks in the lab but playing out over hundreds to thousands of meters. And he also knew that when these relativistic, runaway electrons bounced off air molecules, they could emit gamma rays.
By themselves, these extreme subatomic affairs didnt seem to be abundant enough to account for the brilliant gamma rays lighting up storm clouds. But then Dwyer imagined a baroque process that could allow one avalanche to set off another, and another, and another, all right on top of each other.
According to Dwyers process, when one electron in the avalanche collided with an atom, the electron could ricochet and emit a gamma ray. That gamma ray would transform into an electron and its antimatter twin, a positron. The clouds electric field would push the positron backward close to where the avalanche began. There it could crash into another atom, setting off another avalanche, which would make more gamma rays, more positrons, more avalanches, and so on, until you got a flash visible from orbit.
-snip-
In the New Mexico desert, a pair of stations bristling with antennas captured radio waves coming out of a dozen separate lightning strikes. Using this data, Xuan-Min Shao, a researcher at Los Alamos National Laboratory, was able to reconstruct the way the overall current moved during the start of these strikes. He found that something was off. If one of Dwyers cascades, or any other process driven purely by the electric field, was seeding the lightning bolt, the proto-bolt would move perfectly in line with the electric field from the very beginning of the process. But Shao found that in these cases, the two directions were slightly at odds. In the slant, Shao sees evidence for an extraterrestrial, even extragalactic origin for lightning a cosmic-ray shower.
-snip-
Dwyer knew that a Russian physicist, Aleksandr Gurevich, had shown in 1992 that such a runaway electron could unleash a cascade of perhaps 100,000 electrons, akin to the avalanches that initiate sparks in the lab but playing out over hundreds to thousands of meters. And he also knew that when these relativistic, runaway electrons bounced off air molecules, they could emit gamma rays.
By themselves, these extreme subatomic affairs didnt seem to be abundant enough to account for the brilliant gamma rays lighting up storm clouds. But then Dwyer imagined a baroque process that could allow one avalanche to set off another, and another, and another, all right on top of each other.
According to Dwyers process, when one electron in the avalanche collided with an atom, the electron could ricochet and emit a gamma ray. That gamma ray would transform into an electron and its antimatter twin, a positron. The clouds electric field would push the positron backward close to where the avalanche began. There it could crash into another atom, setting off another avalanche, which would make more gamma rays, more positrons, more avalanches, and so on, until you got a flash visible from orbit.
-snip-
In the New Mexico desert, a pair of stations bristling with antennas captured radio waves coming out of a dozen separate lightning strikes. Using this data, Xuan-Min Shao, a researcher at Los Alamos National Laboratory, was able to reconstruct the way the overall current moved during the start of these strikes. He found that something was off. If one of Dwyers cascades, or any other process driven purely by the electric field, was seeding the lightning bolt, the proto-bolt would move perfectly in line with the electric field from the very beginning of the process. But Shao found that in these cases, the two directions were slightly at odds. In the slant, Shao sees evidence for an extraterrestrial, even extragalactic origin for lightning a cosmic-ray shower.
-snip-
And near the end, the article quotes Dwyer saying, "If this mechanism is true, every time you see a lightning flash, there is a physical connection to a dying star somewhere in the galaxy."
2 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
What Causes Lightning? The Answer Keeps Getting More Interesting. (Quanta, 5/6) (Original Post)
highplainsdem
7 hrs ago
OP
Bear in mind ... cloud chambers were one of the ways cosmic rays were originally discovered.
eppur_se_muova
1 hr ago
#2
Inkey
(539 posts)1. This is a great article !!!
I have been studying electromagnetic fields most of my life and have always wondered
about this lightening phenomenon.
This explanation opens a new perspective about this topic !
Hydrometeors is my new word for the day !
eppur_se_muova
(42,377 posts)2. Bear in mind ... cloud chambers were one of the ways cosmic rays were originally discovered.
Cloud chambers and spark-gap chambers are routinely used to study subatomic particles here on Earth. In both devices, the passage of high-energy particles through a sub-critical medium leaves a trail of ionized particles in its wake, which then leads to visible changes of condensation or electrical discharge. If portions of our atmosphere are teetering on the edge of electrical breakdown, why wouldn't we expect to see cosmic rays induce lightning, at least occasionally ? The big question is now: how often ?