Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

marmar

(79,022 posts)
Wed Sep 24, 2025, 08:46 AM Sep 24

Erika Kirk can't keep Charlie's audience [View all]


Don’t worry — Erika Kirk will never replace her husband
She can't replicate his brand of gutter misogyny

By Amanda Marcotte
Senior Writer
Published September 24, 2025 6:45AM (EDT)


(Salon) Before he was killed earlier this month at a speaking event in Utah, one of the most popular video clips featuring Charlie Kirk showed him mocking a college girl for having a wardrobe malfunction. In the clip, a young woman confronts him at one of his ballyhooed “debate” appearances on college campuses. Surrounded by a mob of jeering boys wearing MAGA hats, the girl apologizes and says she’s “very nervous,” and it seems like an accident that her nipple slips out. Temperatures reached a high of 84 degrees that day at the University of Pittsburgh, and she had dressed accordingly, wearing a cropped cami.

But even if she did it on purpose, Kirk’s reaction was disgusting. He rolled out the video on YouTube and his social media channels with headlines that framed the young woman as sexually loose. “SHE TRIES TO FLASH ME!” declared one headline. “Did Hater Try to Flash Charlie Kirk to Get Him Banned on YouTube?” read another.

....(snip)....

The media myth that Kirk was doing politics the “right way” owes everything to pundits who never bothered to look at his actual content. His videos were not about substantive debate. They were just MAGA rage bait. To quote one of his popular tweets, “Who we actually can’t stand are angry, liberal, white women.”

....(snip)....

Despite the relentless efforts of MAGA leaders to compare Kirk to Christ, the reality is the son of God didn’t really build his name on video clips promising, with all-caps headlines, that angry misogynists will get to see a grown man mock scantily clad teenage girls. Kirk’s death was ghastly and contemptible, but in a media environment and country conditioned to move on, its shock is already beginning to wear off. To replace her husband, Erika Kirk will have to give the slobbering MAGA masses the same titillating, abrasive content in which her husband specialized.

Frankly, I don’t think she’s up to it. ......................(more)

https://www.salon.com/2025/09/24/dont-worry-erika-kirk-will-never-replace-her-husband/




33 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
TPUSA will go bankrupt in a couple of years. valleyrogue Sep 24 #1
"Moved on to where" is the question TheProle Sep 24 #11
TP going bankrupt would be great, but IzzaNuDay Sep 25 #33
And JD won't keep Trump's momentum lame54 Sep 24 #2
Yup, it's a cult of personality. GoCubsGo Sep 24 #5
J "Davenport" Vance? thomski64 Sep 24 #19
Personality cults disappear when the cult leader dies. sop Sep 24 #3
She's the "wrong" gender. She's suppose to be home taking care of all the babies. Biophilic Sep 24 #4
Also maga totally rejects forgiveness. Too woke, too empathic/sympathetic. Not manly-man enough. . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Sep 24 #8
Ya, empathy is evil, or so St Charlie told us. Biophilic Sep 24 #10
except they are hypocrites, always Kali Sep 24 #15
Some Kirk fans might even suggest that she's practicing DEi, Heaven forbid. nt allegorical oracle Sep 24 #24
Bummer /s Dave Id Sep 24 #6
Ironic, to use the word titillate,when the article is about a nipple malfunction. BattleRow Sep 24 #7
There are videos where people do stupid challenges JI7 Sep 24 #9
Back to the Kitchen and fix my dinner. BurnDoubt Sep 24 #12
The evangelicals will abandon her... SickOfTheOnePct Sep 24 #13
Clarification Requested DET Sep 24 #27
Not when they're born... SickOfTheOnePct Sep 24 #28
Amanda Marcotte always expands and clarifies my vague notions cally Sep 24 #14
Of course not. Charlie's followers assume women submit to men, not lead Raven123 Sep 24 #16
TPUSA was founded in 2012 by Charlie Kirk and Bill Montgomery. Both are dead now. sop Sep 24 #17
I am truly disturbed that he had brakester Sep 24 #30
Kirk's major appeal was to misogynistic young men. No woman, including Erika Kirk, could possibly replicate that appeal. Martin68 Sep 24 #18
Which is the safer bet? USS_Dauntless Sep 24 #20
She'd fit right in with all the other blonde former beauty queens on FOX News. sop Sep 24 #23
Which pays the most? Christian Nationalists don't come cheap. nt allegorical oracle Sep 24 #25
She could hook up with a dude just as awful mdbl Sep 24 #21
She only wants the $$$$$$$$ to keep coming in, obviously. nt Exp Sep 24 #22
His videos were heavily edited. He didn't need to show her mistake. underpants Sep 24 #26
Kirk's real strength brakester Sep 24 #31
I predict they will install Benny Johnson clevergrrrl Sep 24 #29
Erika gfarber Sep 25 #32
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Erika Kirk can't keep Cha...