Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Emrys

(9,150 posts)
3. Scotland regularly generates an electricity surplus over its own requirements
Wed Apr 8, 2026, 10:16 AM
Wednesday

Unfortunately, because of the way the UK grid is regulated, that doesn't mean people in Scotland pay less for electricity than those living in the south, so we put up with some of the negative impacts but don't see all the direct benefits.

There is some resistance to the locating of new windfarms, along with the power lines to support them, but nothing like the hysteria Trump's expressed about their defiling the views from his golf courses.

His insane hatred of wind power in the US may be traceable to his humiliating protracted defeat when he challenged the construction of a sea-based wind farm that would be barely visible with the naked eye from his course at Menie on the Aberdeenshire coast:

How Trump's loathing for wind turbines started with a Scottish court battle

"I am the evidence," was the eyebrow-raising comment made by Donald Trump when he appeared before the Scottish Parliament in 2012.

He was speaking as an "expert" witness on green energy targets, describing how he believed wind turbines were damaging tourism in Scotland.

Five years before he first became US president, it was one of his earliest interventions on renewable energy - but since then his opposition to them has grown to become government policy in the world's biggest economy.

He was objecting to 11 turbines which were planned - and ultimately constructed - alongside his Aberdeenshire golf course.
...
Trump battled the plans through the Scottish courts, then appealed to the UK's Supreme Court - but he was unable to stop the "monsters" from going ahead.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c15l3knp4xyo


The UK's Labour government, like other recent UK governments before it, is pressuring Scotland to allow the building of new nuclear power stations as its ageing nuclear plants near decommissioning. The SNP-led government in Holyrood has long opposed this as ecologically perilous and unnecessary given that Scotland already more than meets its own needs. The innumerable problems, delays and vast cost escalations encountered in building the new nuclear power station Hinkley Point C in Somerset in England haven't helped the UK government's case.

Anyone interested in how the loads on the UK electricity grid work can view the proportions from various sources in use in real time at https://www.gridwatch.templar.co.uk/

The smaller dials in the second row on the right show the two-way interconnector contributions via a network of cables linking the UK, Ireland, France, the Netherlands and other locations on the Continent. The flows will vary dynamically depending on which source has a surplus at any time and the spot price of electricity from that source.

Recommendations

7 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

We could learn a lot from our European friends if we would get our head out of our ass. walkingman Wednesday #1
It has NOTHING to do with our heads up our asses. Conjuay Wednesday #2
Both are true. yardwork Wednesday #6
Scotland regularly generates an electricity surplus over its own requirements Emrys Wednesday #3
Decades of these kinds of momentary 100% reports demonstrate... NNadir Wednesday #4
This isn't a "momentary" surplus, nor is it unreliable. Emrys Wednesday #7
Nonsense. It isn't rocket science to understand that the wind doesn't blow continuously. NNadir Wednesday #9
I was just thinking the other day I hadn't seen an NNadir pro-nuke post in awhile AZJonnie Wednesday #10
Wind power will only prolong our dependence on fossil fuels. hunter Wednesday #13
Yes I've read many dozens of NNadir's posts over the years, you don't have to get me up to speed AZJonnie Wednesday #15
The best ways to halt human population growth are not coercive. hunter Wednesday #16
Nuclear power will have a similar effect Emrys Wednesday #18
Low wind and no sunshine cause renewable energy shutdowns constantly. hunter Wednesday #20
Hence my emphasis throughout on a MIX of resources Emrys Wednesday #23
Trashing coastal environments with tidal power schemes isn't going to save the world. hunter Wednesday #25
This is now getting tiresome. I didn't realize a good news story about Scotland would bring on the nuclear fanboys. Emrys Wednesday #28
Bullshit. Hickley C will be saving lives half a century after every wind turbine in Scotland has become landfill. NNadir Wednesday #21
Oh, bullshit yourself. Emrys Wednesday #24
Thank you. I chose to respond to your question in a new thread over in E&E. It's:... NNadir Saturday #29
Nonsense yourself. I think you fit very well the description of an ideologue Emrys Wednesday #12
Could it be that's what the fossil fuel industry wants you to think? hunter Wednesday #17
I don't know why you think that. Emrys Wednesday #19
Human ingenuity sometimes (not often, but sometimes) Torchlight Wednesday #5
really good DoBW Wednesday #8
They will need to be bombed over this and their regime changed. Too threatening to Big Oil. (SARCASM). artemisia1 Wednesday #11
Gee. Who WOULDN'T want that for the USA and planet earth? Kid Berwyn Wednesday #14
Wouldn't it be great to read, United States of America temporarily ran entirely on wind power... Passages Wednesday #22
And we get coal natural gas and oil. Klarkashton Wednesday #26
he hated wind power becuase Turbines were in view on the golf course he acquired. Acccording to the Clown-in-Charge, OAITW r.2.0 Wednesday #27
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Scotland temporarily ran ...»Reply #3