Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

MineralMan

(152,152 posts)
Mon Jun 29, 2026, 09:48 AM Jun 29

There's Nothing Intrinsically Wrong with AI - Let Me Explain [View all]

Last edited Mon Jun 29, 2026, 10:27 AM - Edit history (2)

AI can be useful. It's great for things like summarizing masses of text into simpler, more compact information.

It can substitute for humans in generating massive amounts of code in software.

What it cannot do, though, is think or be creative. And that's the flaw that will bring down the extensive hype surrounding AI these days. It cannot generate a new idea, based on imaginative thinking or research. It cannot initiate such research or even suggest that the research be done.

AI cannot think. It cannot create from scratch. It is not real intelligence. It's smart, but not intelligent.

That doesn't mean that it's not important. It does not mean it's useless.

People often compare it to the Tulip frenzy that almost destroyed a nation's economy. There are still tulip farms. There are still people breeding new varieties of tulips. Tulip bulbs still have value, as you'll see if you go shopping for bulbs for your garden. But, Tulips are not a magical key to wealth. They never were. That was a scam that failed.

AI is like tulips. It's valuable in its own way, but it's not a magical fix for economical growth. It does not need thousands of huge data centers. Investing in such things is going to result in a loss for the investors. AI frenzy could easily case a market crash, just as the collapse of the tulip market did in the past.

Use caution. Go look at the AI summaries on several Google searches. Some are good. Some are useful. Some, though, are wacky as can be and are simply incorrect. It takes Real Intelligence to tell the difference. We need RI more than AI.

29 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
There are many varieties of AI, some of which we don't notice or are unaware that they are AI, Ocelot II Jun 29 #1
AI can cause problems, no doubt. MineralMan Jun 29 #2
Agree 100%. If you ask me AI is right up there with crypto as a dangerous investment. Ocelot II Jun 29 #3
Yup. MineralMan Jun 29 #4
Its not really intelligent until it can deal with an unfamiliar situation that is unexpected. haele Jun 29 #18
Further, it cannot create the decision tree you posted MineralMan Jun 29 #20
AI would need very little apart from the same spec doc that you would need to code it yourself AZJonnie Jun 29 #24
My point is that it cannot initiate MineralMan Jun 29 #25
I think you're overlooking intent LearnedHand Jun 29 #5
No, I'm not overlooking that. MineralMan Jun 29 #6
Even MAGA's don't want it. Like me they don't care if it takes a nano second Bengus81 Jun 29 #9
Here's an interesting article I read over the weekend EarlG Jun 29 #7
We are the target being aimed at. Prairie_Seagull Jun 29 #11
Yes, We are targets as is the energy grid and water supplies 31j20b3 Jun 29 #14
Prior to / or along with AI Prairie_Seagull Jun 29 #16
They worship profit, labor costs dig into profit, so they oppose labor 31j20b3 Jun 29 #17
Although AI technology is the new reality of modern life, anciano Jun 29 #8
Thing is tulips didn't replace jobs and disrupt education dalton99a Jun 29 #10
Of course they're not the same, but they are similar in some respects. MineralMan Jun 29 #12
AI is a tool to be used wisely or not. Disaffected Jun 29 #13
But are you sure it's accurate? RussBLib Jun 29 #15
No, just like any other source of information, Disaffected Jun 29 #19
true enough RussBLib Jun 29 #26
The massive water and electricity requirements of AI centres Disaffected Jun 29 #28
Many data centers use... RussBLib Jun 29 #29
Eroding our trust KT2000 Jun 29 #21
I have serious doubts that Artificial Intelligence Miguelito Loveless Jun 29 #22
You're absolutely right. It won't. MineralMan Jun 29 #23
I don't see AI as the Tulip Mania. That would be crypto craze. sakabatou Jun 29 #27
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»There's Nothing Intrinsic...