Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

chowmama

(1,096 posts)
25. So, about 50:50?
Sun Mar 22, 2026, 06:24 PM
Mar 22

Just to be clear, I don't think there's a wrong answer. I guess I'm just a small person who likes small spaces.

Eventually, DH and I will have to find some way to move into a single level or otherwise compatible home, because he's becoming increasingly less good on stairs. The kitchen, master bedroom and bathroom will have to be on the main floor for safety - I can't have him upstairs if he can't get down in case of a fire.

Our current home is an 1884 HUD house which is 2 stories plus full attic and basement, but only one bathroom on the second floor. It was considered a vacation home for a rich person when it was built, just outside the city limits. Second house built on the block. Now, it's considered South Central neighborhood in Minneapolis. The original city limits used to end at Lake Street, 2 blocks north. I only wish it was a hobbit hole.

But I fear I'll end up in a ranch house. I grew up with and in them. Ugh! But they're still preferable to a serf storage unit, for safety as well as for personal taste. Elevators are just as dangerous if there's a fire.

And I still don't want open floor plan. Other opinions may vary.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

No, I don't care for open floor plans at all. sinkingfeeling Mar 22 #1
HATE IT! EarthAbides Mar 22 #2
I like some of them HappyH Mar 22 #3
I think it's different in a cabin, which are for family get togethers. LisaM Mar 22 #21
I'm with you! flor-de-jasmim Mar 22 #4
No. Hate them. Big space, no style or personality. Polly Hennessey Mar 22 #5
Hate it. Ocelot II Mar 22 #6
I have an open concept house and it has it's pros and cons. Kitchen smells spread, and heating/cooling alwaysinasnit Mar 22 #7
I like cozy rooms and pleasant colors. Don't want drab walls and everything open with tile and echoes. TommieMommy Mar 22 #8
My kitchen still has two swinging service doors at both ends... NCDem47 Mar 22 #9
Love an open floor plan .... anciano Mar 22 #10
I very much agree. Big Blue Marble Mar 22 #11
Everyone likes it at first, Captain Zero Mar 22 #12
Most open plan houses are open only on the first floor spooky3 Mar 22 #13
I'm in the "it depends" or middling opinion, I suppose. RockRaven Mar 22 #14
Hate the open look for most of the same reasons... MiHale Mar 22 #15
There's a couple of reasons a hobbit home sounds cool... slightlv Mar 22 #18
I'm one of those who'd prefer a modified open space house. slightlv Mar 22 #16
I like semi-open plans radical noodle Mar 22 #17
I like rooms. Separate rooms. LoisB Mar 22 #19
I recently sold my house that did not have open plan to new rental with open plan FloridaBlues Mar 22 #20
My house is one large room with a full bath and bedroom at the opposite ends. Zackzzzz Mar 22 #22
My dream house would be a straw cob house Niagara Mar 22 #23
In the 1950's JustAnotherGen Mar 22 #30
Oh wow Niagara Mar 22 #31
I cannot live with an open floor plan. Sweet Rosie Red Mar 22 #24
I dropped a friend who had JustAnotherGen Mar 22 #29
Good for you! Sweet Rosie Red Monday #33
Ahhh - the Vanilla Villa look JustAnotherGen Tuesday #34
So, about 50:50? chowmama Mar 22 #25
I'm okay with the oprn plan of my kitchen, keeping room, Ilsa Mar 22 #26
Kitchen enid602 Mar 22 #27
Our Historic JustAnotherGen Mar 22 #28
LOVE LOVE LOVE them ZDU Mar 22 #32
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Household Hints & Help»How many people like an '...»Reply #25