Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Celerity

(55,675 posts)
17. No they are not. We (I live in Sweden) in the Nordics have social democracy, not democrat socialism. None of the nations
Sun Jul 5, 2026, 07:34 PM
Jul 5

you listed are democratic socialist.

We social democracy-manifesting Nordics all have very robust, vibrant, AND also highly regulated capitalist economies that work synergistically with expansive social welfare state sectors to provide some of the highest standards of living on the planet.

I have been trying to point this out almost since I joined here in summer 2018.

What socialism is — according to Bernie Sanders

https://bigthink.com/the-present/what-is-socialism-bernie-sanders/

snip

He goes a bit into the particulars of policy and explained that his conception of socialism would require — this is what it would look like — universal health care, total employment, free college education, more public spending, a living wage, environmental regulations, and a robust democratic culture to come into existence. He flatly denied any interest in nationalization, telling the audience:

So the next time you hear me attacked as a socialist, remember this: I don’t believe government should own the means of production, but I do believe that the middle class and the working families who produce the wealth of America deserve a fair deal.

The contents of this speech were very similar to other statements he has made about socialism across his entire political career. The entire speech could have been summed up neatly in a quote he gave to the Associated Press back in 1997:

To me, socialism doesn’t mean state ownership of everything, by any means, it means creating a nation, and a world, in which all human beings have a decent standard of living.

snip

WAIT A MOMENT, PRAISE FOR THE NEW DEAL? NO INTEREST IN NATIONALIZATION? THAT DEFINITION SOUNDS A LOT LIKE CAPITALISM!

snip

Bernie’s explanation of “socialism” is, in fact, closer to what political philosophers refer to as “social democracy.” This is a capitalist system, since the means of production are still privately owned, where the state heavily regulates the economy and has an active welfare system in place to correct for the worst problems inherent to capitalism like inequality, cyclic instability, or the profit motive encouraging people to do things against the public interest.


Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

If we're explaining, we're losing. Democratic candidates should just run on Scrivener7 Jul 5 #1
Do you believe those idiots would understand a food bank for pets? MerryBlooms Jul 5 #12
How about we talk about securing Medicare and Medicaid and Social Security and food and housing security, stopping Scrivener7 Jul 5 #15
I'm talking about immediate results though MerryBlooms Jul 5 #18
Thank you Cirsium Jul 5 #19
Exactly. The problem, though, is that the media ALWAYS picks it up and runs with it. We need a message Scrivener7 Jul 5 #20
They're good at name calling. paleotn Jul 5 #25
Trump's little group LilElf70 Jul 5 #27
And seriously... buzzycrumbhunger Jul 5 #2
We need pet food banks, hygiene centers... Dems should be doing this in their town halls in every district MerryBlooms Jul 5 #14
In many places in the United States, that would drop like a stone. I love Mamdani. I don't care what Scrivener7 Jul 5 #21
Soviet Communist Leadership were public sector Oligarchs bucolic_frolic Jul 5 #3
Communism means abolition of private property. Is anyone calling for that? Jeez! dedl67 Jul 5 #4
they might call that "cultural marxism" rampartd Jul 5 #5
Cultural Marxism is a far-right antisemitic conspiracy theory that misrepresents Western Marxism (especially the Celerity Jul 5 #11
yes, of course, but cultural marxism is another fuzzily defined boogie man rampartd Jul 5 #16
To paraphrase Samuel Johnson: "Playing the Communist card is the last refuge of a scoundrel." sop Jul 5 #6
They are gonna bitch about anything we do gay texan Jul 5 #7
Calling democrats names is all they have right now. HappyH Jul 5 #8
Canada, England, Germany, Norway, Sweden, Finland, Denmark, etc... GiqueCee Jul 5 #9
No they are not. We (I live in Sweden) in the Nordics have social democracy, not democrat socialism. None of the nations Celerity Jul 5 #17
I too have been trying to point that out to no avail. harumph Jul 5 #23
Why bring facts into the discussion... GJGCA Jul 5 #24
Apologies for the misunderstanding, but... GiqueCee Jul 6 #37
Recommended for Epsteinth time! madinmaryland Jul 5 #10
If they're not socialists Progressive dog Jul 5 #13
Yeah ... see, it's the "restraint" part that the billionaires have a problem with FakeNoose Jul 5 #22
Another Republican scare word dlk Jul 5 #26
Republicans have been calling democrats socialists since the Un-American Activities Committee Blue Full Moon Jul 5 #28
This meme needs to go viral. LilElf70 Jul 5 #29
Trumpers won't see this. They ignorantly believe any lie MAGA tells them especially if it's racist. ChicagoTeamster Jul 5 #30
No one on the left SHOULD be making that claim. Conservatives are dumbasses who don't know the difference and use Karasu Jul 5 #31
That's too complicated for the other side MIButterfly Jul 6 #32
We Dems (and especially Democratic Socialists) don't truly understand the impact of brainwashing. summer_in_TX Jul 6 #33
The biggest political mistake Bernie Sanders ever made is in calling himself a "Democratic Socialist." Intractable Jul 6 #34
If you're explaining and defining... you're losing. QueerDuck Jul 6 #35
I know this. You know this. 30% of the population DenaliDemocrat Jul 6 #36
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»For the Epsteinth Time - ...»Reply #17